Using the “Five Whys” to Identify Root Causes
Japan’s weak productivity and poor automotive quality, compared to the United States, was well known, leading Toyota to begin concentrating on improvement. Ohno, an industrious engineer, put his attention to eliminating inefficiencies in the production line. His personal goal was to match, if not exceed, the productivity of U.S. automotive production. From post-war to the 1970s, Ohno and his co-workers worked systematically at driving out waste and inefficiencies. Their process became known as the Toyota Production System (TPS). And as consumers can attest, the quality of Japanese vehicles soared in the late 20th Century. The irony is that years later American and European automotive manufacturers would copy the TPS.
Ohno’s journey wasn’t easy; he met a lot of resistance from management on the need to radically change production methods. But he persisted. Eventually Toyota, as a huge corporation, embedded quality and the elimination of waste (see lean manufacturing).
One of the thinking processes that Ohno developed has become known as “The Five Whys.” He didn’t see problems in a negative light but rather as an “opportunity in disguise.” The word “Kaizen,” meaning continuous improvement, has become embedded in manufacturing around the world. As Toyota’s website explains on “The Five Whys:”
Observe the production floor without preconceptions. Ask ‘why’ five times about every matter.
[Ohno] used the example of a welding robot stopping in the middle of its operation to demonstrate the usefulness of his method, finally arriving at the root cause of the problem through persistent enquiry:
“Why did the robot stop?”
The circuit has overloaded, causing a fuse to blow.
“Why is the circuit overloaded?”
There was insufficient lubrication on the bearings, so they locked up.
“Why was there insufficient lubrication on the bearings?”
The oil pump on the robot is not circulating sufficient oil.
“Why is the pump not circulating sufficient oil?”
The pump intake is clogged with metal shavings.
“Why is the intake clogged with metal shavings?”
Because there is no filter on the pump.
Through this line of inquiry, it’s possible to identify the root cause of a problem. And it doesn’t have to be a manufacturing process to employ it.
Ohno’s work has been applied not only to manufacturing settings but more broadly to the functioning organizations. Peter Senge, MIT lecturer and author of the acclaimed bestseller The Fifth Discipline: The Art and Practice of the Learning Organization, integrated The Five Whys into System Thinking. Briefly, System Thinking involves stepping back to see the big picture when approaching a problem, and how it is part of a bigger system. So rather than react to a specific event, for example, effort’s needed to identify its relationship to other events. As Senge explains:“It is a framework for seeing interrelationships rather than things, for seeing patterns of change rather than static ‘snapshots’.”
This is where The Five Whys can be very useful, whether on a production line, an organization’s recruitment process, or an airline’s customer service practices. It enables one to drill down to root causes when problems emerge that initially get blamed on the “system.” What gets overlooked is that human beings created the “system.”
Here’s a simple example of The Five Whys, using the airline industry as an example:
Q. Why did the passenger’s checked bags not arrive at her destination?
Because they were sent to Dallas airport instead of Miami.
Q. Why were her bags sent to Dallas?
Because the baggage handlers weren’t paying attention.
Q. Why were the baggage handlers not paying attention?
Because they’re angry at management with the delay in settling their collective agreement.
Q. Why is there a delay in the agreement?
Because of management’s insistence on a pay freeze because the airline is losing money.
Q. Why is the company losing money?
A. Because it hasn’t invested in a new computerized tracking system as its competitors have done.
This is along the line of enquiry one could take with a problem that plagues airline passengers.
The Five Whys can be a powerful tool in distilling what may first appear as an overly complicated problem with tentacles extending everywhere. However, bringing people together to collaboratively explore a problem can produce, in a relatively short time, surprising solutions.
Effective questioning brings insight, which fuels curiosity, which cultivates wisdom.
— Chip Bell
Click here to download a complimentary copy of Jim’s e-book Becoming a Holistic Leader, 3rd Edition.
Visit Jim’s e-Books, Resources and Services pages.
Contact Jim for information on his Holistic Leadership Workshop
"""
Articles from Jim Taggart
View blogWe’ve all had good bosses, and more likely bad bosses that outnumber the former. This post is a more ...
Many years ago, I watched Eco-Challenge 2000 on the Discovery Channel (a show that ran from 1995 to ...
Today, we’ll look at the four stages of team development and incorporate the four team player styles ...
Related professionals
You may be interested in these jobs
-
bookkeeper
Found in: Talent CA 2 C2 - 3 days ago
Chucks Roadhouse Bar & Grill Waterloo, CanadaEducation: · Expérience: · Education · College/CEGEP · or equivalent experience · Tasks · Keep financial records and establish, maintain and balance various accounts using manual and computerized bookkeeping systems · Maintain general ledgers and financial statements · Prepare ...
-
Hair Dresser
Found in: beBee S2 CA - 1 day ago
Southbridge Care Homes Cornwall, Canada TEMPORARYHome: Southbridge Cornwall · Location: Cornwall, ON · Position: Hairdresser/contract · We all know how much a haircut and some grooming can make a difference in our lives and confidence. So imagine the difference it makes in the lives of our seniors Southbridge Care Homes are cur ...
-
Réceptionniste / commis administratif
Found in: Talent CA C2 - 6 days ago
Quantum Montréal-Est, Canada PermanentPoste : réceptionniste / commis administratif · Lieu de travail : Montréal-Est · Salaire : 50 k$ à 55 k$ · Vous vous épanouissez dans un environnement dynamique et aimez offrir un service à la clientèle exceptionnel ? Vous êtes soucieux du détail et possédez de solides compétence ...
Comments
Jim Taggart
7 years ago #2
Much appreciated, Ken.
Ken Boddie
7 years ago #1