Royce Shook

5 years ago · 1 minutes of reading · ~10 ·

Blogging
>
Royce blog
>
Why does the Math work?

Why does the Math work?

This is a math problem that is puzzling me, as I am not sure why the math works in this case. So for all you math people out there why does the math work? I want to explain it to my grandson who asked me that question.

An old farmer died leaving his 17 horses to his 3 sons.

When his sons opened up the will it read:

‘My eldest son should get 1/2 (half) of total horses;’

‘My middle son should be given 1/3rd (one-third) of the total horses;’

‘My youngest son should be given 1/9th (one-ninth) of the total horses.’

As it’s impossible to divide 17 into half or 17 by 3 or 17 by 9, the three sons started to fight with each other.

So, they decided to go to a farmer friend who they considered quite smart, to see if he could work it out for them.

The farmer friend read the will patiently, and, after giving due thought, brought one of his own horses over and added it to the 17.

That increased the total to 18 horses.

Now, he divided the horses according to their father’s will.

Half of 18 = 9. So, he gave the eldest son 9 horses.

1/3rd of 18 = 6. So, he gave the middle son 6 horses.

1/9th of 18 = 2. So, he gave the youngest son 2 horses.

Now add up how many horses they have:

Eldest son 9

Middle son 6

Youngest son 2

TOTAL = 17

This leaves one horse over, so the farmer friend takes his horse back to his farm


21ce0d82.jpg

Comments

Ken Boddie

5 years ago#9

#8
Don't encourage me, Royce. Applauding my paltry puns plainly prods me to produce more preposterous pun-ishment, while propagating my perpetration of alliteration. 🤗

Royce Shook

5 years ago#8

#3
Hi Ken, I loved the pun and I had to rein in and corral my laugher, thank you

Greg Rolfe

5 years ago#7

Hi Royce as John demonstrated the math doesn't work but the concept of division does. The fun found in this math problem is due to the unique qualities of Prime numbers. An enjoyable problem.

Greg Rolfe

5 years ago#6

#1
I actually had an accountant friend tell me that one. He was being honest.

Ken Boddie

5 years ago#5

#4
Perhaps with all the ruckus, John Rylance, they should gave brought in the cavalry (also known as the ‘Horse Division’). 🤣😂🤣

John Rylance

5 years ago#4

#3
some would say this horse problem has been asked so often it's a neigh-bore. Of course as the signature tune of the soap, says "Neighbours are there for one another". Not that they are in the program.

Ken Boddie

5 years ago#3

All makes perfect sense to me, Royce. If you have a horse problem then call a neigh-bour. 🤣😂🤣

Royce Shook

5 years ago#2

Hi John, thank you and no it does not matter if they are happy.

John Rylance

5 years ago#1

The original division can't work because 1/2+1/3+1/9 does come to a whole number, but 17/18. The extra horse solves that problem (18/18) The horses can be divided as show. The question then is were they all happy with the outcome. If it does do any reasons why really matter. It reminds me of the joke "Ask an Accountant what's 5+5. He replies what would you like it to be?"

Articles from Royce Shook

View blog
2 weeks ago · 2 minutes of reading

Building a Musical Bridge Between Generations · As we grow older, it’s easy to feel like the world i ...

2 months ago · 1 minutes of reading

Having something to look forward can be a powerful motivator and mood-booster. Here are some ideas o ...

3 weeks ago · 1 minutes of reading

Millennials and the Genre-Melding Revolution · The next wave brought even more change. Millennials, ...

Related professionals

You may be interested in these jobs

  • Work in company

    Grade 11 Math Tutor

    Varsity Tutors, a Nerdy Company

    Remote Grade 11 Math Tutor. Base contract rates start at $18/hour and increase for specialized subjects. Get matched with students best-suited to your teaching style and expertise. · Get paid up to twice per week, ensuring fast and reliable compensation for the tutoring sessions ...

    Fredericton

    1 week ago

  • Work in company

    HSPT Math Tutor

    Varsity Tutors, a Nerdy Company

    The Varsity Tutors Live Learning Platform has thousands of students looking for remote online HSPT Math tutors. · Provide personalized instruction to individual students. · Acept on-demand tutoring requests whenever you're available. · ...

    St. John's

    1 week ago

  • Work in company

    Spirit of Math Teacher

    Spirit of Math Schools Inc.

    The ideal candidate is patient, gregarious and highly dependable. You excel at connecting with children by providing a balance of kindness and firmness. · The Teacher fosters a high trust learning environment, · develops the values and math skills of students, · builds strong rel ...

    Toronto

    1 month ago